Is the System Failing Us?

Author: Farhan Tijani 

Our rights as children are of great importance, but there is the issue with youth representation and advocacy. With society's quick reaction in pointing the fingers of every crime to any young person available. When things go wrong or when a young person makes a slight mistake, the immediate reaction we get is blame, label, stigma, punishment, etc. We are only seen as a problem to be controlled and maintained.

But with no one asking the question “What is wrong?”. 

We have no one questioning the situation, understand our view, and see matters from our perspective. We remain in the dark of the situation when the reality is a totally different situation of young people constantly being blamed for crimes and failures and still leaving us with no proper background education.

A perfect example of this system failure can be seen in the upcoming discussion and proposal of “Social media ban for children under the age of 16.” Instead of providing adequate education beforehand on internet safety, digital literacy, holding the right people and organisations accountable, the blame and fault is only on young people with not enough guidance  and instead the society decides the best way to control it is a power ban. Rather why not guide us than policing behaviours and making it worse.

Again, major and public decisions concerning us young people, our lives, our education, our freedom are made in rooms we are not even aware of, talkless of being allowed into it. We are being talked about, but never talked to. This prevents us having a say in decisions concerning and directly affecting us. 

If decision makers actually took their time to not just listen to us but actually act, they would see things from our perspective, understand our situation better, and work with us to come to a common compromise. Understanding we are just young people who need mentoring, guidance, support, understanding and not control.

And also I would like to admit they are organisations that do take the time to engage, listen, work with, acting with and on behalf of young people like the Irish Second-Level Student Union (ISSU), Comhairle na NóG, Spunout, Jigsaw, etc. But despite their hard work and engagement with some active decision makers in events like Debate Your Decision Makers (DYDM), young people are still left in a vulnerable position of no mandate on whether our concerns are actually put into action or not. 

If the system is ever to change, they would have to stop making decisions for us and start listening to us and working with us to make decisions for us, by us, and with us.